Hamptons Lobster Roll Prices: A Guide to the Best Deals

Spending part of the summer in the Hamptons? We're guessing you have a few priorities during your stay: hitting the beaches, doing some shopping, and finding the perfect lobster roll. But how much do lobster rolls in the Hamptons cost — and is lobster in the Hamptons the same price everywhere? For more ideas while exploring the area, visit Discover Long Island. 

We looked into the costs of the lobster rolls at some of the most popular seafood restaurants currently open in the Hamptons. Here's what we found.

Hot lobster meat with melted butter, or cold lobster salad roll with mayo and celery — what will it be? From casual seafood shacks to fine dining restaurants, here's Yacht Hampton's official list of Hamptons lobster roll prices in order of least to most expensive.

Now let's get to business.

• Stuart's Seafood Market: $32
  

Amagansett

• The Seafood Shop: $32.95 
  

Wainscott

• Bostwick's Chowder House: $34
  

East Hampton

• MTK Lobster House: $34

Montauk

• Le Bilboquet: $34

Sag Harbor

• The Lobster Roll (LUNCH): $34 (Cold), $35 (Hot)

Amagansett, Southampton

• Gosman's Clam Bar: $38

Montauk

• Clam Bar: $38 (Cold), $40 (Hot)

Amagansett

• Inlet Seafood: $38

Montauk

• Carissa's: $38

Amagansett, East Hampton, Sag Harbor

• Duryea's: $44

Montauk, Orient Point

• 668 The Gig Shack: $45

Montauk

• Sel Rrose: $48 (Lunch), $42 (Dinner)

Montauk

• Tillie's at Gurney's: $48

Montauk

• Sant Ambroeus: $59

East Hampton

From the perfectly cooked lobster claw and tail meat to the warm toasted bun, lobster rolls are a classic American summertime meal — a staple you can enjoy from June to September. Whether you're out with the kids or enjoying some time with your friends, next time you view the menu at a Hamptons restaurant and see "MP" or "market price" next to the lobster roll, open up this guide and snap a photo you can show to your friends.

Whether you have your own East End home, you’re renting a summer place, or you're staying at one of the Hamptons hotels in Southampton, Montauk, or anywhere in between, you're sure to be close to one of these go-to rolls destinations — and they're only the beginning of the thriving Hamptons food scene.

If you're looking for more insider guides and restaurant reviews, check out the Top 10 Hamptons Waterside Dining Spots and the 10 Must-Try Hamptons Seafood Restaurants. Plus, if you're renting a charter with Yacht Hampton and want to make a reservation at a specific restaurant, give us a call. We’ll do our best to leverage our 14 years of owner-to-owner relationships and score you a reservation at your dream lobster destination. You can also plan onboard catering or browse our fleet before your lobster-roll cruise.